Turn Negative Reviews Into Positive Opportunities - Grace Hill
Back to Blog

Turn Negative Reviews Into Positive Opportunities

Posted on July 18, 2024 by Tia Calvin Kimbrough

Negative feedback concept. Choosing a 1-star rating review in the survey, poll, or customer satisfaction research. Bad user experience via a smartphone. Customer experience dissatisfied. Poor rating
Negative feedback concept. Choosing a 1-star rating review in the survey customer satisfaction research
negative, feedback, unsatisfied, review, dissatisfied, poor, bad, 1, low, one, star, rating, satisfaction, survey, poll, experience, questionnaire, customer, concept, user, smartphone, mobile, phone, dislike, evaluation, business, rate, client, performance, consumer, marketing, disappointment, man, businessman, complaint, standing, evaluate, criticism, measurement, grade, yellow, internet, awful, disappointed, terrible, question, rank, choice, online, closeup

Jump to a Section


In today’s digital age, your online reputation is a crucial bridge between residents and property management. It fosters a two-way street of communication, allowing residents to voice their experiences and onsite teams to gain valuable insights. 

Positive reviews highlight the things you’re doing well, but they can also be a springboard for further communication. For example, a resident mentioning a fantastic community event in their review opens the door to discussing future events with new prospects. But ignoring reviews, especially negative ones, is like slamming the door shut on this vital feedback loop. 

This blog explores the value of a negative review in building trust and how property managers can leverage Online Reputation Management (ORM) insights to pinpoint areas for improvement.

Building Trust Through Transparency

While a glowing five-star rating is the most desired, a perfect record might raise a skeptical eyebrow for potential renters. Negative reviews give your property credibility. By embracing all reviews, both positive and negative, you can foster open communication and use resident feedback to continuously improve your property.  

A 2024 study by BrightLocal revealed that while 54% of consumers appreciate a response to positive reviews, a staggering 88% expect businesses to address all reviews. That means simply acknowledging praise isn’t enough.

A mix of positive reviews highlighting your strengths, alongside thoughtful responses to any negative concerns, paints a more authentic picture of your property and demonstrates your commitment to resident satisfaction. 

A 2024 study by BrightLocal revealed that while 54% of consumers appreciate a response to positive reviews.

The Power of the Prompt Reply 

As you consider your online reputation, remember this: Reviews are the way your residents share their biggest pain points. They aren’t just negative sentiments but instead gold mines of opportunity. Someone took time to share that you didn’t live up to their expectations; it’s up to you to accept the feedback and take action!

Reviews can also help identify larger trends among residents. One person’s discontent offers a chance to uncover weaknesses in your product, service, or overall experience. But, their frustration could be a window into a much bigger issue. Their experience might reflect a silent problem impacting many of your customers. 

In fact, data shows that 96% of unhappy customers won’t even complain, but 91% of those will simply leave. By proactively addressing one person’s concern, you can prevent a wave of dissatisfaction from leaving your property. Embrace this feedback as a chance to learn and make things right, ultimately leading to a better experience for everyone.

Disappointed customers who leave a review are giving you a second chance. To protect your online reputation and regain trust, here are three simple steps to take when your property receives a negative review.

  1. Respond promptly:  A timely response demonstrates that the property management team values resident feedback and is committed to resolving issues. Ideally, aim to respond within the first 24-48 hours. AI tools, like Grace Hill’s ORM solution, can be valuable assets to streamline your strategy, helping busy managers craft personalized, authentic responses and automate review monitoring.
  2. Address their issue: Addressing negative reviews head-on fosters trust and transparency with potential residents. When residents see you actively working to improve their experience, it emphasizes your dedication to providing a quality living environment. This positive online presence can influence their decision-making process, tipping the scales in your favor when compared to properties that remain silent.
  3. Show them you care about their satisfaction: When businesses demonstrate their willingness to engage with customers (even when faced with criticism), they showcase their commitment to excellent customer service, building a powerful bridge to loyalty. And it stands in stark contrast to competitors who might ignore resident concerns. 

From Complaint to Resolution

Don’t underestimate the importance of responding to negative reviews and having a resolution strategy in place. Khoros, a global leader in digital customer engagement, revealed, “If you want to build customer loyalty, not lose it, ramping up your brand’s customer service efforts is the best place to start.” In fact, 83% of customers reported a significant increase in loyalty toward brands that address and resolve their complaints. 

Think of a complaint as an opportunity to turn a dissatisfied resident into a loyal brand advocate. By actively listening to a resident’s concerns and taking steps to address them effectively, you demonstrate that you value their feedback, which fosters trust and strengthens relationships. 

Consider a review where a resident mentions ongoing noise complaints. This seemingly negative feedback could be a catalyst for positive change. 

By implementing noise reduction measures and following up with the resident online, the property demonstrates responsiveness and a commitment to the resident’s well-being. This transparency builds trust and paints a more realistic picture of the property — a place that values resident feedback and strives for continuous improvement.

Proactive ORM is Your Competitive Advantage

Reviews can act as a window into what local properties may be doing well. By analyzing the issues raised by unhappy residents, you can identify areas for improvement and adapt your offerings to better meet their expectations. This proactive approach demonstrates your dedication to continuous improvement and positions you as a leader in resident satisfaction, setting your property apart from the competition.

Don’t shy away from negative reviews — see them as a chance to improve and solidify your property’s competitive edge! Remember, negative reviews are occasions to connect with residents and strengthen your online reputation. By leveraging them as a feedback communication channel, you demonstrate a commitment to resident satisfaction. 

Embrace these opportunities to listen, learn, and adapt. After all, a thoughtful response to a negative review can turn a frustrated resident into a loyal advocate, and that’s a valuable asset for any property. 

Simplify Your Property’s Online Reputation Management

Running a multifamily property is tough. Managing your online reputation shouldn’t be! With so much information across multiple sites and social platforms, keeping up with it all can be challenging. Using a tool to consolidate your online reputation to track trends and alert you when new reviews emerge helps you respond with less administrative effort. By utilizing a comprehensive ORM solution like Grace Hill, you can be sure you never miss an opportunity to engage.

Grace Hill gives you a single dashboard view of your reviews, listings, social media, and key performance metrics. We help you respond to reviews faster, boost social media engagement, and leverage customer insights to attract new tenants. 

Ready to simplify your online reputation? Request a free demo today and see how Grace Hill can transform your online presence. 

Tia Calvin Kimbrough is a Product Marketing Manager at Grace Hill specializing in driving revenue growth and increasing brand awareness. With a versatile skill set encompassing social media strategy, product marketing, copywriting, demand generation, content creation, and design, Tia has a track record of crafting collaborative and creative campaigns. She specializes in people-oriented and purpose-driven marketing across B2B software marketing, while also partnering with small businesses and diverse groups to bring a uniquely inclusive lens to her work. Tia holds degrees from Lipscomb University in Journalism and a Master’s from the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University. Learn more about Tia’s background and experience on her LinkedIn page and website.

Learn More About The Author

Scroll to Top